Are you scarred by what he put you through?
Is that why you treat me like you do?
You keep building walls that I can't break through

What can I do to prove myself to you?
Just because he was unfaithful doesn't make me a cheater
Just because he wasn't true doesn't make me a liar

Can't you see that he ain't me? (he ain't me)
This is now how it's supposed to be
No way I can win, guilty until proven innocent

Now I'm paying for his sins
This shouldn't seem like deja vu
'Cause I can't stand the thought of hurting you
But you keep pushing me farther away

Even when I'm begging you to stay
Just because he was unfaithful doesn't make me a cheater
Just because he wasn't true doesn't make me a liar

Can't you see that he ain't me? (he ain't me)
This is now how it's supposed to be
No way I can win, guilty until proven innocent
Now I'm paying for his sins

It's unfair to compare
Everytime you needed me I've been right there
I just know I can't hold on
Unless you let it go

Just because he was unfaithful doesn't make me a cheater
Just because he wasn't true doesn't make me a liar

Can't you see that he ain't me? (he ain't me)
This is now how it's supposed to be
No way I can win, guilty until proven innocent
Now I'm paying for his sins