There she goes
Walked right up to her and said
Why won't you be mine
Halloween played its tricks on me
And cupid decided to stop by
I knew you were to good to be true

As the night passed on
There's so much to look at
But my eyes were locked on you
You told me your name
You gave me your smiles
And you told me to come back by 2am
I knew you were to good to be true

Now I'm here dying, just to hear your voice
By calling a number that just wonÕt work
I should've known better
But who's to blame
But all my efforts you put to shame
I knew you were to good to be true

Always I knew, she was to good to be true
Always I knew
Always I tried, no matter how she left me
Always I tried