Can you blame me
For still having thoughts about you and I
Call me crazy
But it's hard to let go when we never really said goodbye

Did you shake me
Are you just killing time with him
Did you erase me
Or do you still wonder what might have been
Cause I still wonder
I still wonder

What a story line we made
But we put a bookmark in the page
And we said we'd pick it up another day
With chapters still left to be told
You've found someone new to hold
How are you not curious to know how the rest of our story goes

Do you remember
Endless nights at the jersey shore
Do you ever
Wish for just one more afternoon in bed til four
Do you still wonder
Cause I still wonder

What a story line we made
But we put a bookmark in the page
And we said we'd pick it up another day
With chapters still left to be told
You've found someone new to hold
How are you not curious to know how the rest of our story goes

Why can't we just pick things up where we left off
Like we said we would
Would we have let each other go
If we new back then it would be for good

What a story line we made
But we put a bookmark in the page
And we said we'd pick it up another day
With chapter's still left to be told
You've found someone new to hold
How are you not curious to know how the rest of our story goes