I know you better with the lights off
That's the only time it feels like you
There's a piece inside that's missing
It's the only part I ever knew

Smells like your cologne
Trusting all your clothes
I, I
Whose this in my bed?
Tell me who this is
I, I wanna know

I think I fell in love with a stranger
He kisses me goodnight like you used to do
When nothing 'bout this love is familiar
Familiar, I wanna know
I think I fell in love with a stranger
Look into your eyes, no, it can't be you
When nothing 'bout this love is familiar
I think I fell in love with a stranger
(Stranger, stranger, stranger, stranger)

I know you better with the lights off
That's the only time it hurts like you
You know we used to play in harmony
And now you're playing out of tune

Smells like your cologne
Trusting all your clothes
I, I
Whose this in my bed?
Tell me who this is
I, I wanna know

I think I fell in love with a stranger
He kisses me goodnight like you used to do
When nothing 'bout this love is familiar
Oh, I wanna know
I think I fell in love with a stranger
Look into your eyes, no, it can't be you
When nothing 'bout this love is familiar
I think I fell in love with a stranger

Ohh
Ohh, whoa, whoa, whoa
Ohh
Ohh, whoa, whoa, whoa

I think I fell in love with a stranger
He kisses me goodnight like you used to do
When nothing 'bout this love is familiar
Oh, I wanna know
I think I fell in love with a stranger
Look into your eyes, no, it can't be you
When nothing 'bout this love is familiar
I think I fell in love with a stranger (stranger)