I found myself
Singing in the rain
But I'm singing off-key
I'm not dancing
Just drowning in the pain
No Gene Kelly, not tappin' my feet

We used to dance through puddles in September
We'd sing our songs, nobody our age remembers

Our story's not like the classic movies
Doesn't end with you holding me
Won't be getting down on one knee, yeah
This ain't got a happy ending
Cause when the hero comes back
The girl doesn't want him
Fade to black

I realized your love was fake
You were lip-syncing for me
But I didn't see it, I didn't hear it
No, no, no, no, no, no
I was too caught up, caught up in the melody

We used to dance through puddles in September
We'd sing our songs, and you said we'd sing them forever

Our story's not like the classic movies
Doesn't end with you holding me
Won't be getting down on one knee, yeah
This ain't got a happy ending
Cause when the hero comes back
The girl doesn't want him
Fade to black

I save my tears for a rainy day
Trying to hide my heartbreak
In the drops runnin' down my face
I save my tears for a rainy day
I always thought you'd wait for me
Guess I wasn't worth the wait

Our story's more like a modern movie
Depressing apathy too close to reality
There's no escape to a happy ending
When I came back, you were singing with somebody else
Fade to black
I save my tears for a rainy day
Trying to hide my heartbreak
In the drops runnin' down my face
I save my tears for a rainy day
I always thought you would wait for me
Guess I wasn't worth the wait
I save my tears for a rainy day
I always thought you would wait for me