Whatever it was that happened to us
Between popcorn ceilings and magazine dust
Wish I could erase it, if you'd let me go
To somewhere in your head that only you know
There's a bicycle chain stuck in the drain
I wish you off but can't wash you away
And it's flooding the room, but we're both standing still
Don't think it'll kill me, but maybe it will

I'm having trust issues again, oh
I just wish I knew where you had been sleeping
'Cause I wake up covered in bruises from kicking myself
For whatever it was that came between us

Whatever it was that crept its way
To pictures on bookshelves of places we've been
There's a shadow that's casting a hole on the floor
Would you just tell me why we don't talk anymore?

I'm having trust issues again, oh
I just wish I knew where you had been sleeping
'Cause I wake up covered in bruises from kicking myself
For whatever it was that came between us
I'm having night visions again, oh
It feels like you're one step closer to leaving, so
I'll just replay every moment and go on not knowing
Whatever it was that came between us

(Oh)
(Oh)
(Oh)

I'm having trust issues again, oh
I just wish I knew where you had been sleeping
'Cause I wake up covered in bruises from kicking myself
For whatever it was that came between us
I'm having night visions again, oh
It feels like you're one step closer to leaving, so
I'll just replay every moment and go on not knowing
Whatever it was that came between us

(Ah, ooh)
(Ah, ooh)
(Ah, ooh)
(Ah)