You were everything
Every girl's fantasy
I was falling in love

Bet ya drive a fast car
Bet you play the guitar
In a band and the girls go crazy
It's like I'm seeing stars
I'm thinking with my heart
It took a bullet like you to phase me

Well, so much for first impressions
You got me second guessing

You were everything
Every girl's fantasy
I was falling in love
Ya, well it's too bad
You were just something that
I was making up
I liked you... til you liked me

Ooh, you think you're so hot
New kid on the block
Don't mean that you got the right stuff
When you opened your mouth
Nothing came out
If I was looking for lame you'd be awesome

Who knew that twiddling my thumbs
Could be so much fun?

You were everything
Every girl's fantasy
I was falling in love
Ya, well it's too bad
You were just something that
I was making up
I liked you... til you liked me

It all started like 2.5 days ago when:

You showed up on a big white horse
Looking like the one I was looking for
It didn't take long for your cover to blow
Cause you're just a dog (ruff) & pony show

You were everything
Every girl's fantasy
I was falling in love
Ya, well it's too bad
You were just something that
I was making up
I liked you... til you liked me

Chorus 2x